Search

Apache Spark Vs Apache Storm - Head To Head Comparison

In today’s world, the need for real-time data streaming is growing exponentially due to the increase in real-time data. With streaming technologies leading the world of Big Data, it might be tough for the users to choose the appropriate real-time streaming platform. Two of the most popular real-time technologies that might consider for opting are Apache Spark and Apache Storm. One major key difference between the frameworks Spark and Storm is that Spark performs Data-Parallel computations, whereas Storm occupies Task-Parallel computations. Read along to know more differences between Apache Spark and Apache Storm, and understand which one is better to adopt on the basis of different features. Comparison Table: Apache Spark Vs. Apache StormSr. NoParameterApache SparkApache Storm1.Processing  ModelBatch ProcessingMicro-batch processing2.Programming LanguageSupports lesser languages like Java, Scala.Support smultiple languages, such as Scala, Java, Clojure.3.Stream SourcesHDFSSpout4.MessagingAkka, NettyZeroMQ, Netty5.Resource ManagementYarn and Meson are responsible.Yarn and Mesos are responsible.6.Low LatencyHigher latency as compared to SparkBetter latency with lesser constraints7.Stream PrimitivesDStreamTuple, Partition8.Development CostSame code can be used for batch and stream processing.Same code cannot be used for batch and stream processing.9.State ManagementSupports State ManagementSupports State Management as well10.Message Delivery GuaranteesSupports one message processing mode: ‘at least once’.Supports three message processing mode: ‘at least once’, ‘at most once’, ‘exactly once’.11.Fault ToleranceIf a process fails, Spark restarts workers via resource managers. (YARN, Mesos)If a process fails, the supervisor process starts automatically.12.Throughput100k records per node per second10k records per node per second13.PersistenceMapStatePer RDD14.ProvisioningBasic monitoring using GangliaApache AmbariApache Spark: Apache Spark is a general-purpose, lighting fast, cluster-computing technology framework, used for fast computation on large-scale data processing. It can manage both batch and real-time analytics and data processing workloads.  Spark was developed at UC Berkeley in the year 2009. Apache Storm:Apache Storm is an open-source, scalable fault-tolerant, and real-time stream processing computation system. It is a framework for real-time distributed data processing, which focuses on stream processing or event processing. It can be used with any programming language and can be integrated using any queuing or database technology.  Apache Storm was developed by a team led by Nathan Marz at BackType Labs. Apache Spark Vs. Apache Storm1. Processing Model: Apache Storm supports micro-batch processing, while Apache Spark supports batch processing. 2. Programming Language:Storm applications can be created using multiple languages like Java, Scala and Clojure, while Spark applications can be created using Java and Scala.3. Stream Sources:For Storm, the source of stream processing is Spout, while that for Spark is HDFS. 4. Messaging:Storm uses ZeroMQ and Netty as its messaging layer while Spark is using a combination of Nettu and Akka for distributing the messages throughout the executors. 5. Resource Management:Yarn and Meson are responsible for resource management in Spark, while Yarn and Mesos are responsible for resource management in Storm. 6. Low Latency: Spark provides higher latency as compared to Apache Storm, whereas Storm can provide better latency with fewer restrictions.7. Stream Primitives:Spark provides with stream transforming operators which transform DStream into another, while Storm provides with various primitives which perform tuple level of processing at the stream level (functions, filters). 8. Development Cost:It is possible for Spark to use the same code base for both stream processing and batch processing. Whereas for Storm, the same code base cannot be used for both stream processing and batch processing.  9. State Management: The changing and maintaining state in Apache Spark can be updated via UpdateStateByKey, but no pluggable strategy can be applied in the external system for the implementation of state. Whereas Storm does not provide any framework for the storage of any intervening bolt output as a state. Hence, each application has to create a state for itself whenever required. 10. Message Delivery Guarantees (Handling the message level failures):Apache Spark supports only one message processing mode, viz, ‘at least once’, whereas Storm supports three message processing modes, viz, ‘at least once’ (Tuples are processed at least one time, but can be processed more than once), ‘at most once’  and ‘exactly once’ (T^uples are processed at least once). Storm’s reliability mechanisms are scalable, distributed and fault-tolerant. 11. Fault-Tolerant:Apache Spark and Apache Storm, both are fault tolerant to nearly the same extent. If a process fails in Apache Storm, then the supervisor process will restart it automatically, as the state management is managed by Zookeeper, while Spark restarts its workers with the help of resource managers, who may be Mesos, YARN or its separate manager.12. Ease of Development: In the case of Storm, there are effective and easy to use APIs which show that the nature of topology is DAG. The Storm tuples are written dynamically. In the case of Spark, it consists of Java and Scala APIs with practical programming, making topology code a bit difficult to understand. But since the API documentation and samples are easily available for the developers, it is now easier. Summing Up: Apache Spark Vs Apache StormApache Storm and Apache Spark both offer great solutions to solve the transformation problems and streaming ingestions. Moreover, both can be a part of a Hadoop cluster to process data. While Storm acts as a solution for real-time stream processing, developers might find it to be quite complex to develop applications due to its limited resources. The industry is always on a lookout for a generalized solution, which has the ability to solve all types of problems, such as Batch processing, interactive processing, iterative processing and stream processing. Keeping all these points in mind, this is where Apache Spark steals the limelight as it is mostly considered as a general-purpose computation engine, making it a highly demanding tool by IT professionals. It can handle various types of problems and provides a flexible environment to in. Moreover, developers find it to be easy and are able to integrate it well with Hadoop. 

Apache Spark Vs Apache Storm - Head To Head Comparison

27K
Apache Spark Vs Apache Storm - Head To Head Comparison

In today’s world, the need for real-time data streaming is growing exponentially due to the increase in real-time data. With streaming technologies leading the world of Big Data, it might be tough for the users to choose the appropriate real-time streaming platform. Two of the most popular real-time technologies that might consider for opting are Apache Spark and Apache Storm. 

One major key difference between the frameworks Spark and Storm is that Spark performs Data-Parallel computations, whereas Storm occupies Task-Parallel computations. Read along to know more differences between Apache Spark and Apache Storm, and understand which one is better to adopt on the basis of different features. 

Comparison Table: Apache Spark Vs. Apache Storm

Sr. NoParameterApache SparkApache Storm
1.Processing  ModelBatch ProcessingMicro-batch processing
2.Programming LanguageSupports lesser languages like Java, Scala.Support smultiple languages, such as Scala, Java, Clojure.
3.Stream SourcesHDFSSpout
4.MessagingAkka, NettyZeroMQ, Netty
5.Resource ManagementYarn and Meson are responsible.Yarn and Mesos are responsible.
6.Low LatencyHigher latency as compared to SparkBetter latency with lesser constraints
7.Stream PrimitivesDStreamTuple, Partition
8.Development CostSame code can be used for batch and stream processing.Same code cannot be used for batch and stream processing.
9.State ManagementSupports State ManagementSupports State Management as well
10.Message Delivery GuaranteesSupports one message processing mode: ‘at least once’.Supports three message processing mode: ‘at least once’, ‘at most once’, ‘exactly once’.
11.Fault ToleranceIf a process fails, Spark restarts workers via resource managers. (YARN, Mesos)If a process fails, the supervisor process starts automatically.
12.Throughput100k records per node per second10k records per node per second
13.PersistenceMapStatePer RDD
14.ProvisioningBasic monitoring using GangliaApache Ambari

Apache Spark: 

Apache Spark is a general-purpose, lighting fast, cluster-computing technology framework, used for fast computation on large-scale data processing. It can manage both batch and real-time analytics and data processing workloads.  Spark was developed at UC Berkeley in the year 2009. 

Apache Storm:

Apache Storm is an open-source, scalable fault-tolerant, and real-time stream processing computation system. It is a framework for real-time distributed data processing, which focuses on stream processing or event processing. It can be used with any programming language and can be integrated using any queuing or database technology.  Apache Storm was developed by a team led by Nathan Marz at BackType Labs. 

Apache Spark Vs. Apache Storm

1. Processing Model: 

Apache Storm supports micro-batch processing, while Apache Spark supports batch processing. 

2. Programming Language:

Storm applications can be created using multiple languages like Java, Scala and Clojure, while Spark applications can be created using Java and Scala.

3. Stream Sources:

For Storm, the source of stream processing is Spout, while that for Spark is HDFS. 

4. Messaging:

Storm uses ZeroMQ and Netty as its messaging layer while Spark is using a combination of Nettu and Akka for distributing the messages throughout the executors. 

5. Resource Management:

Yarn and Meson are responsible for resource management in Spark, while Yarn and Mesos are responsible for resource management in Storm. 

6. Low Latency: 

Spark provides higher latency as compared to Apache Storm, whereas Storm can provide better latency with fewer restrictions.

7. Stream Primitives:

Spark provides with stream transforming operators which transform DStream into another, while Storm provides with various primitives which perform tuple level of processing at the stream level (functions, filters). 

8. Development Cost:

It is possible for Spark to use the same code base for both stream processing and batch processing. Whereas for Storm, the same code base cannot be used for both stream processing and batch processing.  

9. State Management: 

The changing and maintaining state in Apache Spark can be updated via UpdateStateByKey, but no pluggable strategy can be applied in the external system for the implementation of state. Whereas Storm does not provide any framework for the storage of any intervening bolt output as a state. Hence, each application has to create a state for itself whenever required. 

10. Message Delivery Guarantees (Handling the message level failures):

Apache Spark supports only one message processing mode, viz, ‘at least once’, whereas Storm supports three message processing modes, viz, ‘at least once’ (Tuples are processed at least one time, but can be processed more than once), ‘at most once’  and ‘exactly once’ (T^uples are processed at least once). Storm’s reliability mechanisms are scalable, distributed and fault-tolerant. 

11. Fault-Tolerant:

Apache Spark and Apache Storm, both are fault tolerant to nearly the same extent. If a process fails in Apache Storm, then the supervisor process will restart it automatically, as the state management is managed by Zookeeper, while Spark restarts its workers with the help of resource managers, who may be Mesos, YARN or its separate manager.

12. Ease of Development: 

In the case of Storm, there are effective and easy to use APIs which show that the nature of topology is DAG. The Storm tuples are written dynamically. In the case of Spark, it consists of Java and Scala APIs with practical programming, making topology code a bit difficult to understand. But since the API documentation and samples are easily available for the developers, it is now easier. 

Apache Spark and Apache Storm Features

Summing Up: Apache Spark Vs Apache Storm

Apache Storm and Apache Spark both offer great solutions to solve the transformation problems and streaming ingestions. Moreover, both can be a part of a Hadoop cluster to process data. While Storm acts as a solution for real-time stream processing, developers might find it to be quite complex to develop applications due to its limited resources. 

The industry is always on a lookout for a generalized solution, which has the ability to solve all types of problems, such as Batch processing, interactive processing, iterative processing and stream processing. Keeping all these points in mind, this is where Apache Spark steals the limelight as it is mostly considered as a general-purpose computation engine, making it a highly demanding tool by IT professionals. It can handle various types of problems and provides a flexible environment to in. Moreover, developers find it to be easy and are able to integrate it well with Hadoop. 

KnowledgeHut

KnowledgeHut

Author

KnowledgeHut is an outcome-focused global ed-tech company. We help organizations and professionals unlock excellence through skills development. We offer training solutions under the people and process, data science, full-stack development, cybersecurity, future technologies and digital transformation verticals.
Website : https://www.knowledgehut.com

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

2 comments

priyanka 05 Aug 2019

The comparison between the apache spark Vs. apache storm is very clear loved it thanks for the article...

Vihaan 16 Aug 2019

This is one of the best article I have ever seen. Crystal clear. Thanks for this post.

Suggested Blogs

How to install Apache Spark on Windows?

Apache Spark is a fast and general-purpose cluster computing system. It provides high-level APIs in Java, Scala, Python and R, and an optimized engine that supports general execution graphs. It also supports a rich set of higher-level tools including Spark SQL for SQL and structured data processing, MLlib for machine learning, GraphX for graph processing, and Spark Streaming.In this document, we will cover the installation procedure of Apache Spark on Windows 10 operating systemPrerequisitesThis guide assumes that you are using Windows 10 and the user had admin permissions.System requirements:Windows 10 OSAt least 4 GB RAMFree space of at least 20 GBInstallation ProcedureStep 1: Go to the below official download page of Apache Spark and choose the latest release. For the package type, choose ‘Pre-built for Apache Hadoop’.The page will look like below.Step 2:  Once the download is completed unzip the file, to unzip the file using WinZip or WinRAR or 7-ZIP.Step 3: Create a folder called Spark under your user Directory like below and copy paste the content from the unzipped file.C:\Users\\SparkIt looks like below after copy-pasting into the Spark directory.Step 4: Go to the conf folder and open log file called, log4j.properties. template. Change INFO to WARN (It can be ERROR to reduce the log). This and next steps are optional.Remove. template so that Spark can read the file.Before removing. template all files look like below.After removing. template extension, files will look like belowStep 5: Now we need to configure path.Go to Control Panel -> System and Security -> System -> Advanced Settings -> Environment VariablesAdd below new user variable (or System variable) (To add new user variable click on New button under User variable for )Click OK.Add %SPARK_HOME%\bin to the path variable.Click OK.Step 6: Spark needs a piece of Hadoop to run. For Hadoop 2.7, you need to install winutils.exe.You can find winutils.exe from below pageDownload it.Step 7: Create a folder called winutils in C drive and create a folder called bin inside. Then, move the downloaded winutils file to the bin folder.C:\winutils\binAdd the user (or system) variable %HADOOP_HOME% like SPARK_HOME.Click OK.Step 8: To install Apache Spark, Java should be installed on your computer. If you don’t have java installed in your system. Please follow the below processJava Installation Steps:Go to the official Java site mentioned below  the page.Accept Licence Agreement for Java SE Development Kit 8u201Download jdk-8u201-windows-x64.exe fileDouble Click on Downloaded .exe file, you will the window shown below.Click Next.Then below window will be displayed.Click Next.Below window will be displayed after some process.Click Close.Test Java Installation:Open Command Line and type java -version, then it should display installed version of JavaYou should also check JAVA_HOME and path of %JAVA_HOME%\bin included in user variables (or system variables)1. In the end, the environment variables have 3 new paths (if you need to add Java path, otherwise SPARK_HOME and HADOOP_HOME).2. Create c:\tmp\hive directory. This step is not necessary for later versions of Spark. When you first start Spark, it creates the folder by itself. However, it is the best practice to create a folder.C:\tmp\hiveTest Installation:Open command line and type spark-shell, you get the result as below.We have completed spark installation on Windows system. Let’s create RDD and     Data frameWe create one RDD and Data frame then will end up.1. We can create RDD in 3 ways, we will use one way to create RDD.Define any list then parallelize it. It will create RDD. Below is code and copy paste it one by one on the command line.val list = Array(1,2,3,4,5) val rdd = sc.parallelize(list)Above will create RDD.2. Now we will create a Data frame from RDD. Follow the below steps to create Dataframe.import spark.implicits._ val df = rdd.toDF("id")Above code will create Dataframe with id as a column.To display the data in Dataframe use below command.Df.show()It will display the below output.How to uninstall Spark from Windows 10 System: Please follow below steps to uninstall spark on Windows 10.Remove below System/User variables from the system.SPARK_HOMEHADOOP_HOMETo remove System/User variables please follow below steps:Go to Control Panel -> System and Security -> System -> Advanced Settings -> Environment Variables, then find SPARK_HOME and HADOOP_HOME then select them, and press DELETE button.Find Path variable Edit -> Select %SPARK_HOME%\bin -> Press DELETE ButtonSelect % HADOOP_HOME%\bin -> Press DELETE Button -> OK ButtonOpen Command Prompt the type spark-shell then enter, now we get an error. Now we can confirm that Spark is successfully uninstalled from the System.
9272
How to install Apache Spark on Windows?

Apache Spark is a fast and general-purpose cluster... Read More

5 Big Data Challenges in 2020

The year 2019 saw some enthralling changes in volume and variety of data across businesses, worldwide. The surge in data generation is only going to continue. Foresighted enterprises are the ones who will be able to leverage this data for maximum profitability through data processing and handling techniques. With the rise in opportunities related to Big Data, challenges are also bound to increase.Below are the 5 major Big Data challenges that enterprises face in 2020:1. The Need for More Trained ProfessionalsResearch shows that since 2018, 2.5 quintillion bytes (or 2.5 exabytes) of information is being generated every day. The previous two years have seen significantly more noteworthy increments in the quantity of streams, posts, searches and writings, which have cumulatively produced an enormous amount of data. Additionally, this number is only growing by the day. A study has predicted that by 2025, each person will be making a bewildering 463 exabytes of information every day.A report by Indeed, showed a 29 percent surge in the demand for data scientists yearly and a 344 percent increase since 2013 till date. However, the searches by job seekers skilled in data science continue to grow at a snail’s pace at 14 percent. In August 2018, LinkedIn reported claimed that US alone needs 151,717 professionals with data science skills. This along with a 15 percent discrepancy between job postings and job searches on Indeed, makes it quite evident that the demand for data scientists outstrips supply. The greatest data processing challenge of 2020 is the lack of qualified data scientists with the skill set and expertise to handle this gigantic volume of data.2. Inability to process large volumes of dataOut of the 2.5 quintillion data produced, only 60 percent workers spend days on it to make sense of it. A major portion of raw data is usually irrelevant. And about 43 percent companies still struggle or aren’t fully satisfied with the filtered data. 3. Syncing Across Data SourcesOnce you import data into Big Data platforms you may also realize that data copies migrated from a wide range of sources on different rates and schedules can rapidly get out of the synchronization with the originating system. This implies two things, one, the data coming from one source is out of date when compared to another source. Two, it creates a commonality of data definitions, concepts, metadata and the like. The traditional data management and data warehouses, and the sequence of data transformation, extraction and migration- all arise a situation in which there are risks for data to become unsynchronized.4. Lack of adequate data governanceData collected from multiple sources should have some correlation to each other so that it can be considered usable by enterprises. In a recent Big Data Maturity Survey, the lack of stringent data governance was recognized the fastest-growing area of concern. Organizations often have to setup the right personnel, policies and technology to ensure that data governance is achieved. This itself could be a challenge for a lot of enterprises.5. Threat of compromised data securityWhile Big Data opens plenty of opportunities for organizations to grow their businesses, there’s an inherent risk of data security. Some of the biggest cyber threats to big players like Panera Bread, Facebook, Equifax and Marriot have brought to light the fact that literally no one is immune to cyberattacks. As far as Big Data is concerned, data security should be high on their priorities as most modern businesses are vulnerable to fake data generation, especially if cybercriminals have access to the database of a business. However, regulating access is one of the primary challenges for companies who frequently work with large sets of data. Even the way Big Data is designed makes it harder for enterprises to ensure data security. Working with data distributed across multiple systems makes it both cumbersome and risky.Overcoming Big Data challenges in 2020Whether it’s ensuring data governance and security or hiring skilled professionals, enterprises should leave no stone unturned when it comes to overcoming the above Big Data challenges. Several courses and online certifications are available to specialize in tackling each of these challenges in Big Data. Training existing personnel with the analytical tools of Big Data will help businesses unearth insightful data about customer. Frameworks related to Big Data can help in qualitative analysis of the raw information.
1314
5 Big Data Challenges in 2020

The year 2019 saw some enthralling changes in volu... Read More

Top In-demand Jobs During Coronavirus Pandemic

With the global positive cases for the COVID-19 reaching over two crores globally, and over 281,000 jobs lost in the US alone, the impact of the coronavirus pandemic already has been catastrophic for workers worldwide. While tourism and the supply chain industries are the hardest hit, the healthcare and transportation sectors have faced less severe heat. According to a Goldman Sachs report, the number of unemployed individuals in the US can climb up to 2.25 million. However, despite these alarming figures, the NBC News states that this is merely 20% of the total unemployment rate of the US. Job portals like LinkedIn, Shine, and Monster are also witnessing continued hiring for specific roles. So, what are these roles defining the pandemic job sector? Top In-demand Jobs During Coronavirus Pandemic Healthcare specialist For obvious reasons, the demand for healthcare specialists has spiked up globally. This includes doctors, nurses, surgical technologists, virologists, diagnostic technicians, pharmacists, and medical equipment providers. Logistics personnel This largely involves shipping and delivery companies that include a broad profile of employees, right from warehouse managers, transportation-oriented job roles, and packaging and fulfillment jobs. Presently, Amazon is hiring over 1,00,000 workers for its operations while making amends in the salaries and timings to accommodate the situation.  Online learning companies Teaching and learning are at the forefront of the current global scenario. With most of the individuals either working from home or anticipating a loss of a job, several of them are resorting to upskilling or attaining new skills to embrace broader job roles. The demand for teachers or trainers for these courses and academic counselors has also shot up. Remote learning facilities and online upskilling have made these courses much more accessible to individuals as well.  Remote meeting and communication companies The entirety of remote working is heavily dependant on communication and meeting tools such as Zoom, Slack, and Microsoft teams. The efficiency of these tools and the effectivity of managing projects with remote communication has enabled several industries to sustain global pandemic. Even project management is taking an all-new shape thanks to these modern tools. Moreover, several schools are also relying on these tools to continue education through online classes.  Psychologists/Mental health-related businesses Many companies and individuals are seeking help to cope up with the undercurrent. This has created a surge in the demand for psychologists. Businesses like PwC and Starbucks have introduced/enhanced their mental health coaching. Mental health and wellness apps like Headspace have seen a 400% increase in the demand from top companies like Adobe and GE.  Data analysts Hiring companies like Shine have seen a surge in the hiring of data analysts. The simple reason being that there is a constant demand for information about the coronavirus, its status, its impact on the global economy, different markets, and many other industries. Companies are also hiring data analysts rapidly to study current customer behavior and reach out to public sentiments.  How to find a job during the coronavirus pandemicWhether you are looking for a job change, have already faced the heat of the coronavirus, or are at the risk of losing your job, here are some ways to stay afloat despite the trying times.  Be proactive on job portals, especially professional networking sites like LinkedIn to expand your network Practise phone and video job interviews Expand your work portfolio by on-boarding more freelance projects Pick up new skills by leveraging on the online courses available  Stay focused on your current job even in uncertain times Job security is of paramount importance during a global crisis like this. Andrew Seaman, an editor at LinkedIn notes that recruiters are going by the ‘business as usual approach’, despite concerns about COVID-19. The only change, he remarks, is that the interviews may be conducted over a video call, rather than in person. If the outbreak is not contained soon enough though, hiring may eventually take a hit. 
8536
Top In-demand Jobs During Coronavirus Pandemic

With the global positive cases for the COVID-19 re... Read More