Search

Built Instability Fosters Innovation New Product Development

As funny as the Calvin and Hobbes comic is, it conveys an important message about how creativity and chaos almost always go together. In 1981, when Honda was developing Honda City – the innovative first-of-its-kind compact car – an executive in charge of its development remarked, “It’s like putting the team members on the second floor, removing the ladder, and telling them to jump or else. I believe creativity is born by pushing people against the wall and pressuring them almost to the extreme.” Haven’t most of us experienced this at some point in our lives? The idea of “built-in instability” was first published in a 1986 Harvard Business Review paper, which kicked off the Agile movement. The paper names built-in instability as a top quality of new product development at leading companies such as Honda, Fuji and Canon. Well, what does built-in instability mean? Why is it important? How does it help teams succeed? Let’s address these questions one by one. What built-in instability means When a company’s top leadership does the following: establishes a broad but extremely challenging goal, does not provide a product definition or a work breakdown structure, AND offers the project team ample room for experimentation and failure … this is called built-in instability. The leaders have basically created an environment of constructive chaos to serve as a catalyst for creative output. Why built-in instability matters Honda’s leaders instructed the Honda City project team to develop “the kind of car that the youth segment would like to drive.” Do we see a goal here? Yes. But is the goal well-defined? No. Do we see what kind of product is expected? Uh, maybe. But do we see the steps to get there? No. With a goal like that, the only way leaders can expect the team to succeed is by letting them fail – to fail early, fail often, and fail forward. When a team has the freedom to fail and knows there isn’t a firing squad waiting down the road, it begins to break traditional boundaries. And companies that thrive beyond decades or centuries with avant-garde products do not get there with traditional thinking. This is why built-in instability matters. How built-in instability fosters success Look at the Honda City team’s goal again: to develop “the kind of car that the youth segment would like to drive.” A broad goal like this naturally demands cross-disciplinary work across a broad spectrum of organizational functions – market research, finance, planning design, production, testing, sales and service. When the team wants to succeed while having the luxury to fail, the built-in instability fosters collaboration among individuals from various functions. In the words of a member of the Honda City team: “You then start thinking in terms of what’s best or second best for the group at large and not only about where you stand. If everyone understands the other person’s position, then each of us is more willing to give in, or at least to try to talk to each other. Initiatives emerge as a result.” In sum, what we today use as Agile/Scrum or other modern methodologies essentially relies on built-in instability. By giving teams the freedom to fail, the process encourages a DNA of experimentation, learning, innovation and continuous growth.
Rated 4.5/5 based on 20 customer reviews

Built Instability Fosters Innovation New Product Development

2K
Built Instability Fosters Innovation New Product Development

As funny as the Calvin and Hobbes comic is, it conveys an important message about how creativity and chaos almost always go together.

In 1981, when Honda was developing Honda City – the innovative first-of-its-kind compact car – an executive in charge of its development remarked, “It’s like putting the team members on the second floor, removing the ladder, and telling them to jump or else. I believe creativity is born by pushing people against the wall and pressuring them almost to the extreme.”

Haven’t most of us experienced this at some point in our lives?

The idea of “built-in instability” was first published in a 1986 Harvard Business Review paper, which kicked off the Agile movement. The paper names built-in instability as a top quality of new product development at leading companies such as Honda, Fuji and Canon.

Well, what does built-in instability mean? Why is it important? How does it help teams succeed? Let’s address these questions one by one.

What built-in instability means

When a company’s top leadership does the following:

  • establishes a broad but extremely challenging goal,
  • does not provide a product definition or a work breakdown structure, AND
  • offers the project team ample room for experimentation and failure

… this is called built-in instability.

The leaders have basically created an environment of constructive chaos to serve as a catalyst for creative output.

Why built-in instability matters

Honda’s leaders instructed the Honda City project team to develop “the kind of car that the youth segment would like to drive.”

  • Do we see a goal here? Yes.
  • But is the goal well-defined? No.
  • Do we see what kind of product is expected? Uh, maybe.
  • But do we see the steps to get there? No.

With a goal like that, the only way leaders can expect the team to succeed is by letting them fail – to fail early, fail often, and fail forward. When a team has the freedom to fail and knows there isn’t a firing squad waiting down the road, it begins to break traditional boundaries. And companies that thrive beyond decades or centuries with avant-garde products do not get there with traditional thinking. This is why built-in instability matters.

How built-in instability fosters success

Look at the Honda City team’s goal again: to develop “the kind of car that the youth segment would like to drive.”

A broad goal like this naturally demands cross-disciplinary work across a broad spectrum of organizational functions – market research, finance, planning design, production, testing, sales and service. When the team wants to succeed while having the luxury to fail, the built-in instability fosters collaboration among individuals from various functions.

In the words of a member of the Honda City team: “You then start thinking in terms of what’s best or second best for the group at large and not only about where you stand. If everyone understands the other person’s position, then each of us is more willing to give in, or at least to try to talk to each other. Initiatives emerge as a result.”

In sum, what we today use as Agile/Scrum or other modern methodologies essentially relies on built-in instability. By giving teams the freedom to fail, the process encourages a DNA of experimentation, learning, innovation and continuous growth.

Karthik

Karthik Selvaraj

Blog Author

Karthik Selvaraj is a senior Business Analyst professional and a Certified ScrumMaster®. He works/has worked for India’s leading IT companies and a startup incubated at IIT-Madras. 

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

2 comments

Nanda Lankalapalli 03 Mar 2017

Nice article Karthik! I agree with you that built-in instability is essential for innovation.

Karthik Selvaraj 06 Mar 2017

Thank you, Nanda!

Suggested Blogs

Why do We Get CSM Certification 2019 | KnowledgeHut

Agile software environments are gaining huge growth in today’s world. According to the Scrum Guides website, “Scrum has been adopted by a vast amount of software development companies around the world.” Most of the companies like Ericsson, Microsoft and Spotify are employing Scrum to self-organise their teams. From the study of nearly 5,400 IT projects, it is found that budget is overspent by 45% only because of project overrun. All these deficits can be avoided by becoming professional in Scrum and the possibility of completing a project successfully on time can be improved as well. A Scrum Master Certification not only teaches Agile and Lean methodologies but also serves as a clear proof of proficiency of the employees. These certifications help explain your proficiency level and thus are in demand. Here we solve all your questions about CSM Certification with KnowledgeHut. After CSM training within how many days do I need to take the certification? This is the final step in becoming a Scrum Master. Once the course is completed successfully, Scrum Alliance will send you an e-mail that includes a link which allows you to create login credentials. From then on, you will have 90 days and 2 attempts to clear the test. You can attempt the exam third time by paying $25 and in case it is not cleared in the third attempt also, the course should be re-taken before attempting the exam fourth time. Is your 2-day training enough to clear the certification? Absolutely yes! Our 2 days of training program is often good enough to get started with Scrum for your next project. It is recommended to be well versed with the resources available on the Scrum Alliance website before joining the course. This will help you to grasp the Scrum practices and principles quickly in our 2-day classroom training and clear the exam easily. What next after CSM? Just having a CSM certificate doesn’t mean that you are a professional Scrum Master. You should experience the role of a Scrum Master for a minimum of 2-3 years before you think of reaching new heights in your Agile career. According to Scrum Alliance, a Scrum Master can increase the possibility of project’s overall success and helps organizations in achieving their goals by applying Scrum principles and techniques. Which is more valued, getting certified from Scrum Alliance (Certified Scrum Master) or Scrum.org (Professional Scrum Master)? Both the certifications are competing equally in the Scrum Master world. The CSM exam is generally easy to pass with a passing grade of approximately 69%, where PSM exam requires a minimum of 85% to pass which is difficult when compared to CSM and CSM course fee is less comparably. How much should I pay to renew CSM certification? CSM certification requires to be renewed every two years. The first 2 years will be covered in the course fee. After that, $100 needs to be paid to extend the credential for another 2 years from your current expiration date.   What are the benefits of “2-year membership with Scrum Alliance”? Scrum Alliance has introduced a new membership community that offers a strong community experience including member-only content such as trainer- and coach-led webinars, exclusive deep discounts, certification and speciality user groups both specialized and regional, and personalized messaging to communicate with community members. Also, membership allows CSMs to use logo that is designed specially to highlight their credentials. What is the eligibility to become a CSM trainer? One should hold the Certified Scrum Product Owner® designation from Scrum Alliance to become Certified Scrum Trainer, and must: Have strong knowledge on Scrum practices, principles and concepts. Have unique training, presentation and storytelling skills, which helps people understand the concepts easier. Have a proven level of communication with Scrum/Agile community. Co-trained with some of the Certified Scrum Trainers or independently. Is the CSM training a basic level under Agile management? Yes. The CSM course offers training in the fundamentals required for professional Scrum master or a Scrum team member. What is the format of the exam? You will need to pass the CSM test, after completing the course successfully. The test can be taken online. The exam consists of 35 objective type questions and lasts for an hour. You must answer a minimum of 24 questions correct out of 35. You can log out of the exam at any time and come back whenever you want. You can answer the questions in any sequence, bookmark or skip to review later. If not cleared in the 1st attempt, you can take the test 2nd time at no cost. The Scrum Alliance charges a minimum amount from the third attempt.   Who provides the certification? The CSM certification will be issued by Scrum Alliance, the largest, most established and certification organization in the Agile community. KnowledgeHut offers professional training from experienced CSTs. What is the process for applying for the certification? Step  1: Take the CSM course. Step  2: Scrum Alliance will send you a link to create login credentials after completion of course. Now, create your login credentials. Step  3: Take the online CSM test by using those credentials. Step 4: Once the test is completed with the minimum passing score, you will be requested to accept a license agreement. Step 5: After accepting it, you will receive Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) designation from Scrum Alliance and a 2-year membership with Scrum Alliance as well. Does Scrum Alliance offer an online/virtual CSM course? No, Scrum Alliance does not offer any online/virtual certification courses. Because they believe that online training can be effective only for some subjects and understanding Scrum requires a high level of personal interaction. How many PDUs will I be eligible for? You can claim 14-16 PDUs and SEUs by participating in our 2-day training program. What do you mean by SEUs? Scrum Educational Units are credits issued by Scrum Alliance for having completed an academic training successfully that meets a set of learning objectives required to get the CSP certification. Where are SEUs and PDUs applicable? SEUs and PDUs are credits issued by Scrum Alliance and PMI. They identify your commitment to the Agile professional by giving credits for educational achievements you make throughout your career. SEUs and PDUs show your growth of continuing education in a particular field to stay relevant without depending on your own practices. These credits are essential if you want to obtain an official Agile professional certification. Can the CSM online test be taken without undergoing the training? No, it cannot be taken. Scrum Alliance believes that true learning requires in-person training and hands-on experience with a CEC or CST. The CSM exam is not provided as a substitute for formal training. Should I pay separately for the certification fee? No, the course fee paid by the trainer includes the first 2 years of certification fee. What’s the importance of a CSM certificate? Becoming a Certified Scrum Master shows that you have become proficient not only in Scrum but also in applying it within different Scrum environments. It proves your core Scrum knowledge and benefits your organization. CSMs are paid more when compared to non-CSMs. CSM certified professionals have a median pay of $87,579 per year and $78,139 for non-CSMs. What does it mean to have a Certified Scrum Master® (CSM) designation? Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) designation is issued by Scrum Alliance after successful completion of CSM exam. Scrum Alliance believes that an individual with this designation will have in-depth knowledge of Scrum terminologies, principles and practices, enough to fulfil the role of ScrumMaster. To show their experience and deep understanding of Scrum, CSMs are supported to apply for and become CSPs. What are the eligibility criteria for this course and the certification? There are no such strict eligibility criteria for CSM course, but it is recommended to have some basic knowledge of principles and working of overall Scrum processes.To be capable enough to get certified, attend our two-day CSM course offered by our CST (Certified Scrum Trainer). Why KnowledgeHut for CSM? KnowledgeHut is a Global Registered Education Provider (REP) of Scrum Alliance and the instructions you get from this training will help you deliver controlled, high-performing projects with high-quality results. KnowledgeHut also offers: Complete CSM training by CSTs approved by Scrum Alliance. Downloadable material from Scrum Alliance. Tricks and tips from our professional Certified Scrum Master Trainers who have years of experience in using Scrum in a variety of environments. 2-year membership with Scrum Alliance included in the course fee. Hope this article was helpful and addressed all your queries pertaining to Certified Scrum Master training. Get in touch with us to know more about the CSM course.
Rated 4.5/5 based on 20 customer reviews
8885
Why do We Get CSM Certification 2019 | KnowledgeHu...

Agile software environments are gaining huge growt... Read More

Scrumban | best Kanban and Scrum

Scrumban is a blend of Scrum and Kanban. Scrumban is an Agile methodology, created to help the existing Scrum teams in exploring Lean and Kanban concepts in the organization & also Scrum and kanban is deciding new agile benchmark in organization. But, why is there a need of merging Scrum and Kanban methodologies? The discrete syllables “Scrum” and “ban”, are enough to describe the several phases of transition from Scrum to Kanban. Basically, Scrumban is an Agile management framework, that is implemented when the teams opt for Scrum as the working way and use Kanban methodology as a magnifying glass to view, understand and carry out continuous improvement in the work.   Today, many organizations are experiencing some issues with the Scrum methodology, so they steer their way of working to the Kanban methodology. But some of the enterprises have discovered an optimized means of clubbing the methodologies forming ‘Scrumban’, as a new way for the teams to follow.   Why are teams merging Scrum and Kanban?   The need of combining these two concepts is due to the cons of both the technologies. Let us see the disadvantages of Scrum and Kanban methodologies. Cons of Scrum: Scrum works according to the emphatic guide. ‘Sprints must be time-boxed to a month or less’, as mentioned in the the Scrum guide. This rule is deccelerating the working pace of the teams.  Each sprint should result in a potentially releasable product at the end of each increment. Scrum teams are asked to deliver the software- designed, coded and tested to the stakeholders, in a very short span. This causes more ‘anxiety’ among the team members. Scrum teams have to entirely commit to the customers’ requirements. In case they fail to achieve the high-priority target, they might have to decide to add some technical debts to solve the time-boxed problem. Cons of Kanban: Kanban provides a very linear technique of work. It was firstly used in the car manufacturing line, which was successful as well. So, it is believed that the Kanban can only be used in the systems which have repeatable processes.  Kanban is not very useful in complex systems like software development process as the software needs change at each and every point.  Merging Scrum and Kanban Corey Ladas was the first to coin the term “Scrumban”. According to him,  “Scrum can be a useful scaffold to hold a team together while you erect a more optimized solution in place. At some point you can slough off the cocoon and allow the pull system to spread its wings and take flight.”    In one of the article, Corey suggested that the time-box principle, mandated by the Scrum, is no longer necessary. In a recently released book, Ajay Reddy stated- “Although Scrumban has evolved as a framework over the years, it has no definitive guide or definition. In fact, as highlighted early in this book, several “authoritative” sources disagree about what Scrumban actually represents”.   There are a few changes made in the practices of ‘Scrumban over Scrum’. Let us look at those changes: Added some specialized teams and functions Self-organization concept, but with some specific boundaries Applied the policies explicitly in the working styles Queuing theory and the laws of flow are applied   Let us see that how Scrumban is distinct from a Kanban method, as follows: Organized around the teams Prescribed a proper framework for the teams to work instead of just specifying a technique as in Kanban Realized the value of time-boxed iterations Focuses on continuous improvement techniques   The team needs a proper structure and a set of practices as a starting point of any project. Comparatively, Scrum is prescribed more than the Kanban technique. Newly formed teams usually benefit from the structured framework. Those teams who like structure and continuous improvement by the Scrum but want continuous flow which is provided by Kanban can go for the Scrum/Kanban hybrid i.e. Scrumban. Large enterprise framework viz., Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe) and Disciplined Agile Delivery (DAD) make use of the both models- Scrum and Kanban.   We provide both Scrum training & Kanban Training
Rated 4.0/5 based on 20 customer reviews
Scrumban | best Kanban and Scrum

Scrumban is a blend of Scrum and Kanban. Scrumban ... Read More

Top 5 Career Paths for Scrum Masters

Are you a Scrum Master? Will you remain as a Scrum master forever? What are your future plans which can advance your career? Let’s discuss what is beyond Scrum master and understand the scope of the various roles or career paths that Scrum Master can play and the supporting certifications to upskill his/her career.Career Paths for Scrum MasterAgile CoachProduct OwnerMentorManagerManagement RolesLet’s understand each role clearly.Agile CoachIt has become a trend now to become an Agile Coach after achieving the CSM certification. This role will help you to stand out in the crowd. A Scrum Master who is successful in managing the complex tasks and handling the multiple teams can go for the role of the Mentor.  Agile Coach is responsible for facilitating the Agile and Scrum implementation. As an Agile Coach, you help teams in Agile adoption and reach success.To become an Agile Coach, the first step is you should be well-versed with the Scrum concepts. Agile and Scrum Certifications will lead you to enhance your Scrum skills. To call yourself a master in the Scrum, you should become a Scrum Master. Along with this, a Product Owner or any other Development team member in the team can be a good Coach. Having experience in playing all the three Scrum roles (Scrum Master, Product Owner, and the Development team)  will be a great start to your Coaching career. On the contrary, if you are not practicing any of those roles, getting trained in these certifications is the best choice to earn hands-on experience.Agile coach education and training:To become an Agile coach there are plenty of online and in-person courses that will help you build the skills to become an Agile coach. ICP-ACC certification is the most popular in demand certification.To know more about this training, check out our ICP-ACC certification course.Product Owner:While on a Scrum team, if the Scrum Masters like what the team is building more than the act of creating something, then they can be most appropriate candidates to become a Product Owner. Product Owner is another role to which a Scrum Master can make a transition. This is not a part of the career path but it is a movement within a team. The Product Owner role is equal to that of a Scrum Master role which can be taken in order to switch to the Product Owner role.Certification leads to the Product Owner roleThere are two certifications available for a product owner Certified Scrum Product Owner (CSPO) by Scrum Alliance and Professional Scrum Product Owner I (PSPO I) by Scrum.org. to validate and certify their understanding of the role of the product owner and how they would respond to real situations that will challenge them.Mentor:A Scrum Master who has been successful in his current role can step ahead into a role as a mentor to other Scrum Masters. This includes the transmission of knowledge and psychological support to the team. As the team is engaged in the daily use of scrum, the scrum master helps the team to use it more effectively. The main motive behind the scrum master acting as a mentoring is to help the individuals become self-sufficient and the team to become self-organizing.Manager:A good manager is essential to the success of a Scrum process and if the manager is an ex-Scrum Master then he or she will understand the problems clear and support teams in the right way. As a manager, your roles and responsibilities will increase. Management RolesScrum Masters are not to be confused with the Project Managerial role. But some Scrum Masters find this task very interesting while working with the team members closely. Scrum Masters become very proficient at guiding teams after working as a Scrum Master for years. Due to this, many wishes to move to management roles.To conclude:The role of Scrum Master increases the demand for the scrum experts and thus there are great opportunities for the scrum professional. The scrum master career path allows one to build a career in different fields. Choose the best career path and it’s good to know your options.
Rated 4.5/5 based on 1 customer reviews
8984
Top 5 Career Paths for Scrum Masters

Are you a Scrum Master? Will you remain as a Scrum... Read More

Useful links