Apache Kafka Vs Apache Spark: Know the Differences

Read it in 8 Mins

Last updated on
07th Apr, 2022
Published
22nd Aug, 2019
Views
12,086
Apache Kafka Vs Apache Spark: Know the Differences

A new breed of ‘Fast Data’ architectures has evolved to be stream-oriented, where data is processed as it arrives, providing businesses with a competitive advantage. - Dean Wampler (Renowned author of many big data technology-related books)

Dean Wampler makes an important point in one of his webinars. The demand for stream processing is increasing every day in today’s era. The main reason behind it is, processing only volumes of data is not sufficient but processing data at faster rates and making insights out of it in real time is very essential so that organization can react to changing business conditions in real time.

And hence, there is a need to understand the concept “stream processing “and technology behind it. 

So, what is Stream Processing?

Think of streaming as an unbounded, continuous real-time flow of records and processing these records in similar timeframe is stream processing.

AWS (Amazon Web Services) defines “Streaming Data” is data that is generated continuously by thousands of data sources, which typically send in the data records simultaneously, and in small sizes (order of Kilobytes). This data needs to be processed sequentially and incrementally on a record-by-record basis or over sliding time windows and used for a wide variety of analytics including correlations, aggregations, filtering, and sampling.

In stream processing method, continuous computation happens as the data flows through the system.

Stream processing is highly beneficial if the events you wish to track are happening frequently and close together in time. It is also best to utilize if the event needs to be detected right away and responded to quickly.

There is a subtle difference between stream processing, real-time processing (Rear real-time) and complex event processing (CEP). Let’s quickly look at the examples to understand the difference. 

  • Stream Processing: Stream processing is useful for tasks like fraud detection and cybersecurity. If transaction data is stream-processed, fraudulent transactions can be identified and stopped before they are even complete.
  • Real-time Processing: If event time is very relevant and latencies in the second's range are completely unacceptable then it’s called Real-time (Rear real-time) processing. For ex. flight control system for space programs
  • Complex Event Processing (CEP): CEP utilizes event-by-event processing and aggregation (for example, on potentially out-of-order events from a variety of sources, often with large numbers of rules or business logic).

We have multiple tools available to accomplish above-mentioned Stream, Realtime or Complex event Processing. Spark Streaming, Kafka Stream, Flink, Storm, Akka, Structured streaming are to name a few. 

We will try to understand Spark streaming and Kafka stream in depth further in this article. As historically, these are occupying significant market share. 

Apache Kafka Stream: 

Kafka is actually a message broker with a really good performance so that all your data can flow through it before being redistributed to applications. Kafka works as a data pipeline.

Typically, Kafka Stream supports per-second stream processing with millisecond latency.  

Kafka Streams is a client library for processing and analyzing data stored in Kafka. Kafka streams can process data in 2 ways. 

  • Kafka -> Kafka: When Kafka Streams performs aggregations, filtering etc. and writes back the data to Kafka, it achieves amazing scalability, high availability, high throughput etc.  if configured correctly. 

It also does not do mini batching, which is “real streaming”.

  • Kafka -> External Systems (‘Kafka -> Database’ or ‘Kafka -> Data science model’): Typically, any streaming library (Spark, Flink, NiFi etc) uses Kafka for a message broker. It would read the messages from Kafka and then break it into mini time windows to process it further. 

Representative view of Kafka streaming:

 
Representative view of Kafka streaming

Note:

  1. Sources here could be event logs, webpage events etc. etc. 
  2. DB/Models would be accessed via any other streaming application, which in turn is using Kafka streams here. 

Kafka Streams is built upon important stream processing concepts such as properly distinguishing between event time and processing time, windowing support, and simple (yet efficient) management of application state. It is based on many concepts already contained in Kafka, such as scaling by partitioning.

Also, for this reason, it comes as a lightweight library that can be integrated into an application.

The application can then be operated as desired, as mentioned below: 

  1. Standalone, in an application server
  2. As a Docker container, or 
  3. Directly, via a resource manager such as Mesos.

Why one will love using dedicated Apache Kafka Streams?

  • Elastic, highly scalable, fault-tolerant
  • Deploy to containers, VMs, bare metal, cloud
  • Equally viable for small, medium, & large use cases
  • Fully integrated with Kafka security
  • Write standard Java and Scala applications
  • Exactly-once processing semantics
  • No separate processing cluster required
  • Develop on Mac, Linux, Windows

Apache Spark Streaming:

Spark Streaming receives live input data streams, it collects data for some time, builds RDD, divides the data into micro-batches, which are then processed by the Spark engine to generate the final stream of results in micro-batches. Following data flow diagram explains the working of Spark streaming. 

Apache Spark Streaming

Spark Streaming provides a high-level abstraction called discretized stream or DStream, which represents a continuous stream of data. 

DStreams can be created either from input data streams from sources such as Kafka, Flume, and Kinesis, or by applying high-level operations on other DStreams. Internally, a DStream is represented as a sequence of RDDs. Think about RDD as the underlying concept for distributing data over a cluster of computers. 

Why one will love using Apache Spark Streaming?

It makes it very easy for developers to use a single framework to satisfy all the processing needs. They can use MLib (Spark's machine learning library) to train models offline and directly use them online for scoring live data in Spark Streaming. In fact, some models perform continuous, online learning, and scoring.

Not all real-life use-cases need data to be processed at real real-time, few seconds delay is tolerated over having a unified framework like Spark Streaming and volumes of data processing. It provides a range of capabilities by integrating with other spark tools to do a variety of data processing.  

Spark Streaming Vs Kafka Stream

Now that we have understood high level what these tools mean, it’s obvious to have curiosity around differences between both the tools. Following table briefly explain you, key differences between the two. 

Sr.NoSpark streamingKafka Streams
1Data received form live input data streams is Divided into Micro-batched for processing.processes per data stream(real real-time)
2Separated processing Cluster is requriedNo separated processing cluster is requried.
3Needs re-configuration for Scaling Scales easily by just adding java processes, No reconfiguration requried.
4At least one semanticsExactly one semantics
5Spark streaming is better at processing group of rows(groups,by,ml,window functions etc.)Kafka streams provides true a-record-at-a-time processing capabilities. it's better for functions like rows parsing, data cleansing etc.
6Spark streaming is standalone framework.Kafka stream can be used as part of microservice,as it's just a library.

Kafka streams Use-cases:

Following are a couple of many industry Use cases where Kafka stream is being used: 

  • The New York Times: The New York Times uses Apache Kafka and Kafka Streams to store and distribute, in real-time, published content to the various applications and systems that make it available to the readers.
  • Pinterest: Pinterest uses Apache Kafka and the Kafka Streams at large scale to power the real-time, predictive budgeting system of their advertising infrastructure. With Kafka Streams, spend predictions are more accurate than ever.
  • Zalando: As the leading online fashion retailer in Europe, Zalando uses Kafka as an ESB (Enterprise Service Bus), which helps us in transitioning from a monolithic to a micro services architecture. Using Kafka for processing event streams enables our technical team to do near-real time business intelligence.
  • Trivago: Trivago is a global hotel search platform. We are focused on reshaping the way travellers search for and compare hotels while enabling hotel advertisers to grow their businesses by providing access to a broad audience of travellers via our websites and apps. As of 2017, we offer access to approximately 1.8 million hotels and other accommodations in over 190 countries. We use Kafka, Kafka Connect, and Kafka Streams to enable our developers to access data freely in the company. Kafka Streams powers parts of our analytics pipeline and delivers endless options to explore and operate on the data sources we have at hand.

Broadly, Kafka is suitable for microservices integration use cases and have wider flexibility.

Spark Streaming Use-cases:

Following are a couple of the many industries use-cases where spark streaming is being used: 

  • Booking.com: We are using Spark Streaming for building online Machine Learning (ML) features that are used in Booking.com for real-time prediction of behaviour and preferences of our users, demand for hotels and improve processes in customer support. 
  • Yelp: Yelp’s ad platform handles millions of ad requests every day. To generate ad metrics and analytics in real-time, they built the ad event tracking and analyzing pipeline on top of Spark Streaming. It allows Yelp to manage a large number of active ad campaigns and greatly reduce over-delivery. It also enables them to share ad metrics with advertisers in a timelier fashion.
  • Spark Streaming’s ever-growing user base consists of household names like Uber, Netflix, and Pinterest.

Broadly, spark streaming is suitable for requirements with batch processing for massive datasets, for bulk processing and have use-cases more than just data streaming. 

Dean Wampler explains factors to evaluation for tool basis Use-cases beautifully, as mentioned below: 

Sr.NoEvaluation CharacteristicResponse Time windowTypical Use Case Requirement
1.Latency tolerancePico to Microseconds (Real Real time)Flight control system for space programs etc.
Latency tolerance< 100 MicrosecondsRegular stock trading market transactions, Medical diagnostic equipment output
Latency tolerance< 10 millisecondsCredit cards verification window when consumer buy stuff online
Latency tolerance< 100 millisecondshuman attention required Dashboards, Machine learning models
Latency tolerance< 1 second to minutesMachine learning model training
Latency tolerance1 minute and abovePeriodic short jobs
(typical ETL applications)
2.Evaluation Characteristic
Transaction/events frequency
Typical Use Case Requirement
Velocity<10K-100K per secondWebsites
Velocity>1M per secondNest Thermostat, Big spikes during specific time period.
3Evaluation Characteristic
Types of data processing
NA

Data Processing Requirement

1. SQL
NA
2. ETL
3. Dataflow
4. Training and/or Serving Machine learning models
Data Processing Requirement1. Bulk data processingNA
2. Individual Events/Transaction processing
4.Evaluation Characteristic
Use of tool
NA

Flexibility of implementation1. Kafka : flexible as provides library.NA
2. Spark: Not flexible as it’s part of a distributed framework

Conclusion

Kafka Streams is still best used in a ‘Kafka -> Kafka’ context, while Spark Streaming could be used for a ‘Kafka -> Database’ or ‘Kafka -> Data science model’ type of context.

Although, when these 2 technologies are connected, they bring complete data collection and processing capabilities together and are widely used in commercialized use cases and occupy significant market share. 

Profile

Shruti Deshpande

Blog Author

10+ years of data-rich experience in the IT industry. It started with data warehousing technologies into data modelling to BI application Architect and solution architect.


Big Data enthusiast and data analytics is my personal interest. I do believe it has endless opportunities and potential to make the world a sustainable place. Happy to ride on this tide.


*Disclaimer* - Expressed views are the personal views of the author and are not to be mistaken for the employer or any other organization’s views.