Agile techniques, such as Scrum and the Scaled Agile Framework, have grown in popularity in the project management sector in recent years. Scrum and SAFe (Scaled Agile Framework) are two distinct frameworks that operate in accordance with Agile and Lean ideas and ideals. Both are quite popular in organizations and public knowledge of them is growing. Both of them appear to be similar on the surface.
However, there are minor distinctions between them and this blog on Scrum vs SAFe will help you distinguish between these major frameworks. So let us get started.
Scrum vs SAFe: Head-to-head Comparison
To better understand what is SAFe Agile vs Scrum, we take a quick look at the table below:
Parameter | Scrum | SAFe |
---|
1. Organization structure | Suited for smaller organizations or independent development teams | Suited for large organizations with interconnected teams |
2. Development philosophy | Continuous development emphasizing speed | Goal-setting framework based on organizational needs |
3. Implementation | Works with small teams with simple goals | Works on an organizational level with complex goals |
4. Processes | The process is defined by iterative and flexible software delivery. | The process has distinct objectives with a predetermined schedule. |
5. Framework requirements | Scrum must be embraced by the whole team. | SAFe must be embraced by the whole team. |
6. Team roles | Less than a dozen members split into three roles. | Numerous employees are divided into several roles. |
7. Dependencies | Coordination is key within teams. | Alignment is key between teams. |
8. Time frame | Sprints are two weeks or longer. | Sprints are shorter. |
Difference Between Scrum and SAFe: Detailed Comparison
Let’s explore the major points of difference between SAFe and Scrum to aptly recognize their unique features!
1. Scrum vs SAFe: Definitions
What Is Scrum?
Scrum is a management methodology that empowers teams to self-organize and collaborate toward a common goal. It specifies a collection of meetings, tools, and roles that are necessary for effective project delivery. Scrum of Scrums SAFe techniques enables teams to self-manage, learn from experience, and adapt to change. Scrum is used by software teams to address complex issues cost-effectively and sustainably.
Scrum is used efficiently by all types of teams, including HR, marketing, and design. Scrum, is more common among software development and engineering teams. It enables teams to respond to changing requirements more quickly while keeping expenses and budgets under control.
Magora Systems What Is SAFe?
SAFe, or Scaled Agile Framework, is an agile framework designed for teams that are program, team, and portfolio. Furthermore, SAFe allows a product team to be flexible. Additionally, it aids in the management of some of the issues that larger organizations have while implementing Agile. SAFe is a large knowledge foundation of established best practices. SAFe is also used by product teams to produce successful software products.
Scaled Agile adds a layer of administration and coordination to the development of sophisticated solutions that are too large and complex for a single Scrum team to handle.
2. Scrum versus SAFe: Organization structure
The major difference between Agile Scrum and SAFe is that they cater to distinct organizational structures. Scrum aligns well with smaller companies or those working with independent teams. Conversely, SAFe is tailored for larger enterprises where interconnected teams collaborate on enterprise-scale projects. The choice between SAFe versus Scrum depends on the organization's size and the nature of team collaboration. Small companies or those emphasizing autonomy may find Scrum more suitable, while larger enterprises requiring synchronized efforts across interconnected teams may lean towards implementing SAFe.
Example: Spotify, the music streaming service, used Agile methodology and Scrum to transform their engineering culture and deliver high-quality products. Scrum allowed them to iterate and change according to market needs to deliver products sooner.
3. Scrum vs SAFe: Development philosophy
The difference between SAFe Agile and Scrum is that they embody different development philosophies. Scrum emphasizes cost-effective continuous development, empowering self-contained teams to efficiently deliver high-quality software with ongoing enhancements. It fosters a sense of project ownership among the teams, which is crucial for success.
In contrast, highlighting the difference between Scrum and SAFe, SAFe is tailored for large enterprises. It combines agility with stability and structured team dynamics. SAFe adopts a formalized approach, setting clear targets aligned with client needs. Given that requirement changes impact multiple interconnected groups, SAFe strategically balances adaptability with the need for coordinated and stable development practices.
Example: Tesla’s adoption of Scrum in their autonomous vehicle project gave a 15% boost to their development cycle. It also led to a 10% drop in errors, showcasing the effectiveness of the methodology even in engineering-related projects.
4. SAFe vs Scrum: Implementation
The Agile Scrum vs SAFe implementation depends on the overall strategic vision of the organization in question. Scrum can be opted when a cohesive operation by a small team is essential for projects with straightforward goals. That’s because the framework excels at simplifying workflows and promoting autonomy within teams.
SAFe is useful when the whole organization needs to be integrated seamlessly. Its implementation necessitates collaboration across teams and establishing a unified approach to achieve organizational objectives. SAFe is a good strategy for large organizations that look for synchronization and adaptability across interconnected teams. Before making the decision of Scrum vs. SAFe, organizations should bear in mind that the Agile framework should strategically align with their overarching strategy.
Example: Lego is a fine example of an organization that reaped the benefits of the Agile framework. While Scrum transformed the teams, they were only able to cooperate fully after the implementation of SAFe.
5. SAFe vs Scrum: Processes
When it comes to difference between Scrum and SAFe Agile in process, Scrum relies on flexible and streamlined methods to break big projects into manageable steps. Regular assessments are conducted to avoid problems, and this keeps the momentum strong, especially on tough projects. Adjustments after stakeholder feedback also flow seamlessly.
SAFe, on the other hand, relies on defined roles that are not tied to small, flexible teams. The processes in SAFe guarantee quality and cooperation across the entire business. Although it demands more upfront planning, the payoff is access to greater resources.
It is essential to understand that each framework has its merits. When looking at Scrum vs. SAFe, Scrum excels in adaptability and momentum, while SAFe brings structured roles and broader resources to the table.
Example: Cisco is a great case study for a large-scale organization that moved away from the waterfall methodology and replaced it with a steady delivery of new features.
Collidu 6. Scrum vs. SAFe: Framework requirements
Scrum thrives with just one team, which emphasizes the independence and self-management the methodology promotes. The ideal Scrum team operates autonomously to accomplish tasks and achieve goals. The difference between SAFe and Scrum is that SAFe demands a broader organizational commitment. It requires teams to collaborate openly, sharing goals and processes in a more cohesive and unified manner.
While Scrum excels with a single self-managing team, SAFe scales up, emphasizing the need for organizational alignment and a unified approach across teams for effective implementation. The choice of Scrum vs. SAFe depends on the level of organizational commitment and the scale of Agile implementation an organization wants to incorporate into its operations.
Example: When PlayStation had to collaborate with over 1,000 engineering team members, Scrum just wouldn’t cut it. Implementation of SAFe cut down planning time by 29% and saved $30 million a year.
7. SAFe vs Scrum: Team roles
One of the most significant Scrum vs SAFe Agile differences shows up in team roles. Scrum excels in small teams, ideally with a dozen or fewer members, where roles are distinctly defined, such as Product Owner, Scrum Master, and the Scrum team. With this basic framework, Scrum is capable of efficiently structuring an entire startup or small business.
SAFe, on the other hand, spans multiple teams within an organization, involving employees at various levels, such as entry-level, managerial, and high-level engineers. The framework introduces roles such as Release Train Engineers, Program Managers, Value Stream Engineers, Solution Architects, Epic Owners, and Product Owners.
The hierarchical structure is necessary for collaboration and alignment across different tiers of the organization, making it well-suited for larger enterprises with intricate structures. Those who work in these structures also study PMP online for better coherence with their roles.
8. Scrum vs SAFe: Dependencies
Team dependencies differ across Scrum vs. SAFe methodologies. Scrum allows teams to self-organize and handle tasks independently, minimizing dependencies on other teams. On the flip side, SAFe introduces more coordination demands between numerous teams, amplifying dependencies. In essence, Scrum emphasizes autonomy and reduced interdependence, while SAFe, with its broader organizational scope, requires a more intricate web of collaboration to manage dependencies effectively.
Example: Fitbit successfully used Scrum to deliver to their clients on time and schedule. However, as their customer base grew, they had to pivot to SAFe to scale.
9. Scrum vs Scaled Agile Framework: Timeframe
Going over Agile Scrum vs SAFe by timeframe, Scrum, teams typically operate within one- to four-week cycles, fostering agility and adaptability. Meanwhile, SAFe teams adhere to approximately two-week cycles, striking a balance between frequent iterations and a more structured approach.
These sprint variations align with each framework's principles, with Scrum emphasizing flexibility and rapid progress, while SAFe combines agility with a slightly more organized and synchronized development pace.
Looking to study PMP online and take your career to the next level? Look no further than our comprehensive online PMP course. With our program, you'll gain the skills and knowledge needed to achieve mastery in project management and become a sought-after professional in your field. Enroll today and start your journey towards success!
Similarities Between Scrum and SAFe
Above we've seen how is safe agile different from scrum, now we'll look into the similarities between Scrum and SAFe:
- Both Scrum and SAFe have a Continuous Delivery Pipeline (CDP). Continuous Delivery Pipeline (CDP) describes the activities, procedures, and automation required to lead a new piece of functionality from inception through on-demand delivery of the product to the end user. Regardless of the fact that it is connected with SAFe and is a more advanced concept, Scrum and CDP's sprint cycle have significant parallels.
- Scrum and SAFe both use the inspect and adapt strategies. An inspection is performed at the end of each sprint in Scrum. Similarly, several checks are performed throughout the SAFe release train. The inspection results are used to adapt development initiatives.
- SAFe and Scrum both encourage continuous cooperation with stakeholders. Analyzing requirements, receiving feedback on deliverables, creating modifications based on customer recommendations, obtaining their stop before deployment, and collaborating with them after deployment are all standard working methods in SAFe and Scrum.
- All development activities are carried out at the Team Level in both Scrum and SAFe. A team in Scrum builds a sprint plan collaboratively, participates in daily standup meetings, offers end outputs, and engages in analytical meetings to further enhance their process.
Along with development activities, all activities are completed at the team level.
- An inspection is carried out at the end of each sprint in Scrum. Similarly, several checks are performed throughout the SAFe release train. The inspection results are used to adapt development initiatives.
- The primary goal of Scrum's smaller product development cycles and SAFe's longer solution development cycles will be to deliver the highest quality to consumers in smaller increments. It allows customers to get the product to market faster.
- When time is set aside for something, this is known as timeboxing. With Scrum timeboxing typically lasts two weeks. SAFe release trains are timeboxes. They normally last three months.
What Should Web Developers Choose When It Comes to Scrum vs SAFe?
“Scrum or SAFe?” This might be a very confusing choice for many. Both frameworks come with their own set of advantages and shortcomings. However, whenever you have to make a choice between the two for yourself, see what matches your best interests.
Here are a few common factors that you must keep in mind before choosing between the two:
- The goal that your organization wants to reach
- Level of involvement among the management of the company
- Reason behind the implementation of SAFe agile vs Scrum
- Framework of the organization
- Size of the organization in terms of workforce
- Nature of project management in the company
Engage with the top trending Agile Category Courses
Conclusion
Scrum vs SAFe are both popular frameworks used in Agile project management, but they differ in their scope and level of detail. Scrum is a simple and flexible framework for small teams that emphasizes collaboration and continuous improvement, while SAFe is a more structured framework for managing large, complex projects that require coordination and alignment across multiple teams and organizational levels. Both Scrum and SAFe come with their own set of advantages and disadvantages.
Companies can choose the better one for themselves depending on their need. Students aspiring to master both should explore the versatile agile management courses offered by KnowledgeHut. These courses will expose students to an array of new and exciting job opportunities in the best companies.
You May Also Like:
What is SAFe Certification? Prerequisites, Cost, Benefits
Top SAFe Certifications
Why you should consider a SAFe® Agile certification
A Glimpse Of The Major Leading SAFe® Versions
Expert Tips to Crack the Safe Agilist Exam in 2024
How To Pass Leading SAFe® Exam?
What Are the 4 Core Values of SAFe
A Complete Guide to SAFe Feature for Scaling Agile
SAFe Agile Vs Agile: The Differences
SAFe Implementation Roadmap – Detailed Guide