What is Expected Monetary Value (EMV)? Formula, Example, Benefits

Driving a project through the project lifecycle is like kayaking in a wild river; imagine rowing against the currents on a valley filled with steep ebbs and high tides - doesn’t it sound scary for a moment? Well, talk to a project manager and hear them say one thing in common, “that is routine.” I do not intend to exaggerate, but when projects transition from planning to execution, there is a lot of chaos that demands the project manager's attention to avoid the ups and downs from escalating and becoming unmanageable. Engaging stakeholders effectively and identifying their needs, influence, and requirements, along with some other tools and techniques, helps project managers analyze areas of risk and strategies to minimize the impact of such risks. Expected Monetary Value (EMV) is one such tool that is often employed by project managers to quantify, manage, and develop strategies for effective project risk management.

What is Expected Monetary Value (EMV)?

By definition, expected monetary value (EMV) is a project management tool that is used to quantify the impact of risks or potential hazards that may impact project objectives and baselines. It is a mechanism that helps project managers numerically weigh and comprehend the implications of risks by evaluating their probability of occurrence and impact on the project. By using EMV, project managers gain valuable insight to prepare risk response strategies, drive decisions based on data, and order risks accordingly. The key implications of this technique by project managers include

1. performing a trade-off in situations that require only one approach/solution out of multiple ones to be considered.
2. Creating a contingency reserve for the project to meet any unforeseen situations

Get hands-on Project Management training and add unique skills through hands-on project management scenarios imparted by expert instructors.

Why Use Expected Monetary Value?

Expected monetary value is an essential project management tool that is used to drive decisions, review priorities, and understand risks. Some of the key reasons to use this tool encompass:

1. Gives weightage to both threats that may occur as well as opportunities that can be advantageous
2. Give importance to the likelihood of occurrence along with considering the probability of occurrence to make thorough decisions
3. Provides an analytical approach to risk prioritization and management
4. A simple and easy formula to enable quick decision-making with the right metrics

Learn about project management in all its dimensions with the industry-awarded training for PMP.

EMV Formula

EMV formula is calculated by considering probability (possibility of occurrence of a risk or untoward event in the project) and impact (the cost that has to be borne should the untoward situation occur) of risks. The expected monetary value formula outcome, i.e., the quantified number obtained by calculating the probability and risk, becomes the project contingency reserve, i.e., reserves set aside for known unknowns. It is important to note that EMV takes into account both negative situations (threats) and positive situations (opportunities), so the EMV of positive situations that may bring opportunities or wins for the project is subtracted from the EMV of negative situations to set aside the project contingency reserves. Let us see both the formula as follows:

“EMV = Probability of risks * Impact of risks

Contingency Reserve = EMV of Opportunities - EMV of threats”

In real-world scenarios, following the EMV calculation is how the insurance industry works by collecting premiums of a certain amount and clubbing them together to meet claim demands, which may be for 1 out of 10 customers who pay premiums. 

Expected Monetary Value Example

Let me walk you through some real-time situations concerning how to calculate the expected monetary value of the projects:

Situation-1 - Operations project facing technological advancement risks

Imagine you are managing operations for a project, and you foresee the risk of technological advancement, which may affect the project. The probability of occurrence of this risk maybe 20%, which may bring financial implications of 125,000 to the organization. As a project manager, here is how you will calculate the expected monetary value example:

EMV = Probability * Impact, so, here, 20% * 125,000 = 25,000

Situation-2 - Software project facing both positive and negative risks

As a project manager for a software project, you identify 3 project risks - the first one has a probability of 60% and can cause a financial implication of $ 1250; the second one has a probability of 25% and can bring a revenue of $4000; the third one has a probability of 30% and can cause an impact of $5000. What will be the EMV and contingency reserves you will maintain?

Risk Number	Type	Amount of Impact (USD)	Probability of occurrence	EMV (USD)
Risk-1	Threat/Negative Risk	1250	60%	-750
Risk-2	Opportunity/Positive Risk	4000	25%	+1000
Risk-3	Threat/Negative Risk	5000	30%	-1,500

Considering the above, the Contingency reserve is calculated as:

“Contingency Reserve = EMV of Opportunities - EMV of threats i.e., 1000-2250 = -1,250”

This is how project managers can assess, evaluate, and weigh the risks to determine EMV in PMP and add the necessary contingency reserves to the project. KnowledgeHut’s Project Management training prepares you for a rewarding career in project management - ace your career by learning from our industry-renowned offerings today.

Expected Monetary Value Analysis

Let us now understand what is expected monetary value analysis - as the name suggests, it is a statistical method of analysis to derive the monetary value of unforeseen events that may happen in the project. This statistical method helps project managers move the project through critical and chaotic situations, all of which are based on a simple mathematical formula. Well, on the other hand, even though the formula may be quite simple, getting the exact number on quantifying the probability involves specific experiences, review of lessons learned from similar projects, expert judgment, and skills of stakeholder negotiation to prioritize and address risks.

Expected Monetary Value Methodology

The expected monetary value calculator is particularly useful for encountering tricky and challenging project situations that demand letting go of one path for the other or prioritizing the risks among the list of identified items to be picked up for strategizing. A brief understanding of the Expected Monetary Value methodology involves gaining a broader understanding of:

1. Detailed analysis of project plan and project documents
2. various sources of project risks,
3. situations that can result in either opportunities or threats for the project,
4. What is the project risk tolerance level,
5. What is the basis of the calculation of the probability levels
6. What kind of projects or management levels are we looking for to decide on the probability of occurrence

Based on the above factors, expected monetary value analysis helps to determine the probability number and contingency reserves to be maintained and managed for the project. Take the online PRINCE2 training certification and understand these and a lot more situational examples of expected monetary value.

Calculating Expected Monetary Value (EMV) [Steps by step]

To come to the proper method of calculating expected monetary value in project management, the project manager must undertake the steps as follows:

1. Identify outcomes: The first step is to identify and list down all possible project outcomes - both positive and negative- that need to be known and documented.
2. Establish outcome values: Second, a value must be assigned to each outcome - this assigned value can be expressed in any monetary/points/other format as per the project governance framework
3. Determine the probability of occurrence of each outcome: Third, the project manager and team must determine the probability of occurrence of each outcome based on objective analysis, expert judgment, or other time-tested techniques.
4. Multiply the outcome and designated value: This step is where the actual calculation of EMV will take place - the project manager will determine the probability of occurrence of the outcome with its assigned value to derive the respective EMV number.
5. Club the EMV to determine contingency reserves: Finally, as the last step - the EMVs are clubbed together to derive the final contingency reserve for the project, which may negate the value of threats with the value of opportunities to determine the reserves needed to meet any emergencies if they occur. The final contingency reserve becomes the output of the project’s EMV risk analysis exercise.

Benefits of EMV in Project Risk Management

In my experience, EMV has brought a lot of benefits for my projects, viz:

• Helps add a quantitative number for analysis, comparison, and mitigation of risks
• Helps build the right amount of contingency reserves during project budgeting
• Simple and easy to calculate and implement, it does not require simulations or other models of analysis that require both time and money investments
• Helps keep track of project risk trends to keep an eye on improvements or deterioration of risks
• Supports the project manager in decision-making and choosing between project alternatives
• Helps discover threats early to allocate reserves and tackle them before they transform by severity into the major.
• Drives resource allocation to the significant or high-severity risks by mitigation strategies
• Guides the project manager to select risk strategies or responses based on objective cost-benefit analysis

The main advantage of utilizing the EMV formula in project management is that it not only considers adverse situations that may affect the project, i.e., negative situations or threats, but also takes into account the positive scenarios that may derive certain advantages for the project, i.e.,,,, opportunities, to come to a weighed and realistic measure for planning the project’s contingency reserves and ways of handling risks.

Alternatives to Expected Monetary Value

Apart from expected monetary value risk analysis, project managers can also utilize some of the following analysis techniques:

1. Expected value 

Expected Value, or EV, quantifies the average outcomes of a series of activities. It is a straightforward measure of the activity outcomes multiplied by the probability of occurrence, considering all outcomes are equally likely to occur (which is often not the case).

“EV = Σ(Probability x Outcome)”

However, it is a measure that is not suitable in real-time project scenarios, considering that not all outcomes may be equally likely.

2. Standard deviation 

Standard deviation, or SD, helps understand the spread level of a data set, i.e., a high standard dataset means a wider range and a low standard dataset means data points are close to the average value, pointing towards a narrower range. SD is used as a risk quantification measure to help understand the deviation of the actual outcome from the expected value. It is calculated as follows:

SD or σ = √Σ((x-μ)2/n)

Here, μ = mean value and n = number of data points.

3. Monte Carlo simulations

Monte Carlo simulations involve modeling analysis and techniques to understand the probability of occurrence of different outcomes by performing a large number of trials. It helps get an estimate of the probability and determine which outcomes can occur more than the others to pay added attention to those.

4. Sensitivity Analysis

Sensitivity analysis, or SA, involves the analysis of outcomes where the inputs are changed or updated. SA is complemented with EMV decision analysis

to identify which inputs will show the most significant impact on project outcomes, as it helps add a layer of analysis to the EMV calculation, yielding more calculated outcomes.

Limitations of Expected Monetary Value Analysis

No wonder Expected Monetary Value is a valuable tool for project managers, but it also has its share of shortcomings, such as:

• Data availability: EMV can be flawed in the absence of accurate and sufficient data.
• Expert Judgement: EMV considers expert judgment to evaluate the probability of impact in the absence of supporting data/lessons learned; this may again result in variations due to subjectivity
• Focus only on financial impacts: EMV focuses only on the financial implications for the project, not taking into account other effects that may result in biased outcomes.
• Basis of calculations: Like expected value, EMV also takes an essential assumption that all outcomes are likely, which is not true and may lead to incorrect judgment of risks.

The above points depict that even a project management method that leans on a statistical approach can get biased and inaccurate. No wonder project management is described more as an art than a science.

Pros and Cons of EMV Analysis

Let us now understand some of the pros and cons of applying the Expected Monetary Value method:

Pros:

• Helps choose between project alternatives using weighted measures
• Straightforward measure of probability and attached monetary value
• Helps take into account both positive and negative project scenarios

Cons:

• Subject to bias due to expert judgment in certain cases
• Can be flawed by inaccurate data
• It can create chaos when contingencies do not occur as perceived and calculated
• Involves a lot of variability with each risk and corresponding calculations

It is important to note that no project management tool can accurately describe or predict project outcomes or risks. However, tools like EMV make decision-making streamlined and a lot easier.

Conclusion

Expected monetary value (EMV) is an invaluable tool for any project manager to perform risk assessment and plan risk response mechanisms. It helps make more informed decisions by quantifying the scenarios based on the probability of risk occurrence and its impact on the project. Using this tool, project managers are enabled to use effective risk prioritization and mitigation, objective and unbiased decision-making, easing choice between situations involving trade-offs, and strategies well-planned resource allocation.

Project managers rely on contingency reserves to meet any unforeseen project situations, and EMV helps build this reserve to be maintained at an optimal level to meet any kind of needs in a project exigency. EMV must be applied in addition to other decision-making methods to reach informed project decisions backed by objective data analysis and a thorough understanding of potential risks and uncertainties that may impact project objectives and/or baselines.