This Festive Season, enjoy 10% discount on all courses Use Coupon NY10 Click to Copy

Search

Lead Or Manage, Which Is The Ideal Approach In An Agile Team?

For all those who live in an Agile world, the word “manager” is not the most loved one. But what is it that makes us feel like that? Why don’t we have the same feelings when we hear the word “leader”? Well, let’s think a bit about it... Often used interchangeably, the terms management and leadership create confusion among people. Some people think that management and leadership are the same thing, others don’t.  In fact, the term leadership in the organizational world is relatively new. A couple of centuries ago, no one would have thought of using it in a work environment. Indeed, great leaders of history were related to politics, philosophy, governments, religion. Some examples are Abraham Lincoln (president of the United States that abolished slavery), Martin Luther King Jr (Baptist minister who led the Civil Rights Movement) and Mahatma Gandhi (who led India to independence and inspired movements for civil rights and freedom across the world), among others. Based on these examples, and if you Google it, you will find several others, we can infer that to lead is to motivate, to inspire, to influence people. And why would someone want to influence others? Well, to share a vision with the team and motivate the team to be aligned to that vision!  So, what makes the difference between a manager and a leader? Basically, it is the approach they use to reach people and the approach they use at work. Leadership is about inspiring and management is about planning. Leaders are focused on aligning people to the organizational vision, which includes obtaining their buy-in, communication, motivation, and inspiration, while managers focus on planning, budgeting, and taking the vision to a reality. Managers follow processes that make organizations successful, they take care of numbers that demonstrate good performance and solve problems when they arise.  Control or inspiration? Basically, managers direct and control. They follow the organization’s policies and processes. Their work is more rational and logical. They create plans and follow them till their success. Managers have to detect risks that may impact their plans and mitigate them. Their objective is to have everything under control, even those plan items that may be at risk since their final goal is to achieve the expected outcome for the team. Management is the practice of manipulating people for personal gain. Leadership is the responsibility of inspiring people for the good of the group. — Simon Sinek (@simonsinek) February 6, 2018 On the other hand, leaders let people be themselves, but at the same time, they share with them the organization’s vision and inspire them to follow it, to be part of a bigger purpose. Leaders understand that forming high performing teams is much better than having individual heroes since diversity is the key to success. This is the reason why their focus is on developing people to its highest performance. Leaders truly believe that this is the path to achieving the expected outcome for the team. Status quo or disruption? Managers ensure that the organization’s policies and processes are followed, but leaders… leaders challenge the status quo. Managers try to ensure that every plan is complete as agreed, but leaders embrace change. They know that change is part of our lives and that if teams do not adapt to change, they may die. This doesn’t mean that managers don’t believe this as well, but their focus is set on achieving goals, as planned. People or processes? Managers create or follow processes and use tools to support the team in the accomplishment of their objectives. Leaders focus on developing people, by coaching them to be a better version of themselves. …..“People over processes”, this is one of the values of the Agile manifesto. And this is the point where we distinguish leaders and managers, and why managers are not “that well seen” in Agile environments.  After having made this comparison, we may now understand those who are against management in Agile environments. Managers seem to be the opposite of what any Agile team may want… However, in order to have successful organizations, there needs to be managers and leaders, people with logical minds and people with innovative ideas. If an organization is run efficiently, then for sure there are leaders and managers in it!! It is the key for organizations to create the correct balance between leadership and management. Of course, “correct balance” may mean something completely different for each organization, and it is their responsibility to define it and achieve it. Achieving it may mean having in your team leaders, managers or people that have management and leadership skills, which gives them and the company a competitive advantage. It is key to understand that both sides of the coin are important. Nowadays, people not only look at their managers for them to assign tasks but for guidance. Teams are eager to grow and improve, teams are eager to embrace change and be challenged. So, what are you waiting for? Challenge them! Give them what they want and they will be high performers, for sure! As Peter Drucker says: “You don’t manage people. Your task is to lead people by making productive their specific strengths and knowledge.” Never forget that in Agile environments, “people” are your highest priority. 
Rated 4.0/5 based on 43 customer reviews

Lead Or Manage, Which Is The Ideal Approach In An Agile Team?

198
Lead Or Manage, Which Is The Ideal Approach In An Agile Team?

For all those who live in an Agile world, the word “manager” is not the most loved one. But what is it that makes us feel like that? Why don’t we have the same feelings when we hear the word “leader”?

Well, let’s think a bit about it...

Often used interchangeably, the terms management and leadership create confusion among people. Some people think that management and leadership are the same thing, others don’t. 

In fact, the term leadership in the organizational world is relatively new. A couple of centuries ago, no one would have thought of using it in a work environment. Indeed, great leaders of history were related to politics, philosophy, governments, religion. Some examples are Abraham Lincoln (president of the United States that abolished slavery), Martin Luther King Jr (Baptist minister who led the Civil Rights Movement) and Mahatma Gandhi (who led India to independence and inspired movements for civil rights and freedom across the world), among others.

Based on these examples, and if you Google it, you will find several others, we can infer that to lead is to motivate, to inspire, to influence people. And why would someone want to influence others? Well, to share a vision with the team and motivate the team to be aligned to that vision! 

Management Quote

So, what makes the difference between a manager and a leader? Basically, it is the approach they use to reach people and the approach they use at work. Leadership is about inspiring and management is about planning. Leaders are focused on aligning people to the organizational vision, which includes obtaining their buy-in, communication, motivation, and inspiration, while managers focus on planning, budgeting, and taking the vision to a reality. Managers follow processes that make organizations successful, they take care of numbers that demonstrate good performance and solve problems when they arise. 

Control or inspiration?

Basically, managers direct and control. They follow the organization’s policies and processes. Their work is more rational and logical. They create plans and follow them till their success. Managers have to detect risks that may impact their plans and mitigate them. Their objective is to have everything under control, even those plan items that may be at risk since their final goal is to achieve the expected outcome for the team.

On the other hand, leaders let people be themselves, but at the same time, they share with them the organization’s vision and inspire them to follow it, to be part of a bigger purpose. Leaders understand that forming high performing teams is much better than having individual heroes since diversity is the key to success. This is the reason why their focus is on developing people to its highest performance. Leaders truly believe that this is the path to achieving the expected outcome for the team.


Status quo or disruption?

Managers ensure that the organization’s policies and processes are followed, but leaders… leaders challenge the status quo. Managers try to ensure that every plan is complete as agreed, but leaders embrace change. They know that change is part of our lives and that if teams do not adapt to change, they may die. This doesn’t mean that managers don’t believe this as well, but their focus is set on achieving goals, as planned.

People or processes?

Managers create or follow processes and use tools to support the team in the accomplishment of their objectives. Leaders focus on developing people, by coaching them to be a better version of themselves.

…..“People over processes”, this is one of the values of the Agile manifesto. And this is the point where we distinguish leaders and managers, and why managers are not “that well seen” in Agile environments. 

people or processes

After having made this comparison, we may now understand those who are against management in Agile environments. Managers seem to be the opposite of what any Agile team may want…

However, in order to have successful organizations, there needs to be managers and leaders, people with logical minds and people with innovative ideas. If an organization is run efficiently, then for sure there are leaders and managers in it!!

Leader & manager difference

It is the key for organizations to create the correct balance between leadership and management. Of course, “correct balance” may mean something completely different for each organization, and it is their responsibility to define it and achieve it.

Achieving it may mean having in your team leaders, managers or people that have management and leadership skills, which gives them and the company a competitive advantage. It is key to understand that both sides of the coin are important. Nowadays, people not only look at their managers for them to assign tasks but for guidance. Teams are eager to grow and improve, teams are eager to embrace change and be challenged. So, what are you waiting for? Challenge them! Give them what they want and they will be high performers, for sure! As Peter Drucker says: “You don’t manage people. Your task is to lead people by making productive their specific strengths and knowledge.”

Never forget that in Agile environments, “people” are your highest priority. 

Gisela

Gisela Provenzano

Blog Author

Gisela is an IT consultant with over 10 years of experience as a Processes and Methodologies SME, Project Manager, Scrum Master and Agile Coach. Her forte includes Agile methodologies like Scrum, Kanban, Scrumban, Pair Programming, and TDD for Data Science and Operations Research projects. Since 2013, she has been working for different accounts like Deloitte, Carnival, Teletech, BBVA, LAN, GAP, Pernod Ricard, K12, iSeatz and Westcon, wherein she was involved in project improvements, processes framework implementation, project management, consultancy and coaching.

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Suggested Blogs

Top 10 Trending Courses in Information Technology for IT Aspirants

The best part to jump to the bandwagon of information technology or IT is, there is an enormous possibility for an individual if he or she starts studying a diploma or a degree, does either a master degree or a research course. He or she can get full-fledged engineering degree. We have listed down here in order of priority, top to down for a beginners to advanced level technical course that an IT aspirant look for. Java or J2E and Its Frameworks Java or J2EE is one of the most trusted, powerful and widely used technology by almost all the medium and big organizations around domains, like banking and insurance, life science, telecom, financial services, retail and much, much more. You have many things to learn in Java or J2EE, like the core part – J2SE, JSP, STRUTS, SPRING and/or HIBERNATE. This is one of the best and most advanced sophisticated applications. If you want to learn Java, you need to start from the ab initio to the advanced level step-by-step. There are many different frameworks as well as supporting technologies to learn for Java aspirants but the given things are must learn and highly demanding in current software market. CISCO Technologies Whether you are fascinated about learning network and switching technologies, then CISCO technologies would be your choice. You can learn CCNA, CCNP and more from CISCO academy. These types of certificates are global certifications. You will get global prospects after completing and learning these types of courses. If you are not coming from engineering backgrounds, then also you can learn CCNA or CCNP, or both. Then you need to take some ad hoc classes for non-engineering students. The great number of fresher and experienced candidate, these days, are pursuing networking courses, if you are one of them, then CISCO technologies can be your choice. A majority of CISCO institutes want degree – graduation in any discipline. SAS – Statistical Analysis System SAS is a popular course. This can be your career as SAS consultant that many medium and large organizations looking for fresher and experienced SAS qualified candidates. This is nothing but a data analytics course that can give you global exposure. The demand for SAS – data analytics is growing day-by-day and the business intelligence domain has emerged one of the most trusted and lucrative option for science graduate. These days, SAS is a’ la mode for fresher and experienced science graduate. It is an integrated system of software products that help to perform critical data-entry, data-retrieval, data-management, data-mining, report writing and graphics. DBA – MySQL – SQL Server In this highly competitive as well as dynamic Software/IT industry, there is one course the one course, which is very popular and can give you stable career is, DBA. This is a course or an ad hoc for students who are interested in learning MySQL and SQL server and like to create, manage as well as maintain the huge data files and other database flavors available in the market. DBA can be your best bet for career-oriented course, when you will be conversant with database with other supporting technologies; you can easily and quickly learn MySQL and DB2 in a much shorter period. The demand for DBA courses are increasing day-by-day and the demand shows the popular it is and the effective career you get after completing these technologies. Microsoft Technologies Microsoft technologies are high in popularity these days. You can be a database developer or a MS technology developer after passing one or multiple certifications, like MCSE, MCAD, MCSD, MCDST, MCDBA, MCAS and others. For enterprise and application development MCITP is one of the best for beginners and advanced level developers. Albeit, this type of certification is not at all a programming certification, but a system maintenance kind of, but have good future prospect. Cloud Computing Today’s biggest buzz in all small, medium and large IT town is all about cloud computing. You must use Google, Amazon etc. some of the big gun of cloud technology. If you are thinking of pursuing a course that can set your future-career in cloud computing, then IaaS, PaaS, SaaS, DaaS etc. would be learnt alpha and omega of cloud computing.
Rated 4.0/5 based on 2 customer reviews
1809
Top 10 Trending Courses in Information Technology ...

The best part to jump to the bandwagon of informat... Read More

Evolution Of Technology, It’s Important To Life

Our conflicting views on whether technology is a boon or bane can be best described by inventor and best selling author Daniel H Wilson, when he says, “We humans have a love-hate relationship with our technology. We love each new advance and we hate how fast our world is changing”. The use of technology is what distinguishes us from other animals and this has been evident throughout history. For our evolution has been deeply linked with the evolution of technology. From discovering the technological potential of fire more than 250,000 years ago to developing watermills as a source of power in the medieval ages, technology today is so futuristic as would have been unimaginable just a few decades back. The industrial age’s greatest aspect was technology. New innovations and devices made life easier. Machines that seem mundane today like the levers, pulleys, wheel and axles, screws and wedges helped usher in an age of productivity. The industrial revolution was to an extent a worldwide phenomenon and this saw technology bringing in progress to the world as a whole. Steam engines, electricity, petroleum and other technological advancements had repercussions throughout society. Coal industry, textile industry, locomotive industry, chemical industry etc brought the world closer. Another important technological advancement was in the field of medicine. Advances in areas of anatomy and physiology enhanced life expectancy and reduced illnesses. By the end of 19th century, the importance of technology had been firmly established and it was clear that dependence on it would only grow. The 20th century saw a range of technologies that evoked both awe and fear in humankind. The airplane, rockets, electronics, antibiotics, and nuclear power managed to create a social situation that offered security but always had danger looming in the fringes. The use and abuse of natural resources brought about rapid growth and prosperity to countries but with such terrible side effects as pollution and depletion of resources. And as we go into the 21st century, technology has reached a whole different level. Communication as we knew it, has changed and has turned passive and more indirect. Pagers, desktop computers and telephones have now been replaced with laptops, tablets and smartphones. People would rather message each other on various platforms rather than talk face to face. In fact, there are almost as many cell phone subscriptions (6.8 billion) as there are people living on this planet (7 billion). By 2014 there were more than 3.8 billion email accounts and this number only keeps growing. Technology today has increased our independence. Need to know where you get the best cakes in town? Just search on the internet. Don’t know how to get to the new mall? Let your GPS take you. Even when it comes to medical care, we have become more self-reliant. The need for doctors to assess our primary health conditions has reduced dramatically with the availability of blood pressure and diabetes monitors. The greatest advantage is the creation of a boundary-less communication channel. Irrespective of your nationality, sex, race or religion, you can communicate with like-minded people from across the world. But as the old adage goes, too much of anything is not good. And this holds true for technology too. Increased use of cell phones and microwave ovens have been linked to diseases caused due to radiations. An over exposure to the virtual world has created a warped sense of reality for many. We have become so attuned to communicating via social media that any face to face communication seems awkward. Technology today does not require us to leave our house. One can work from home, shop from home and receive medical care at home. This has led to isolation, a lack of social skills and an inability to conduct ourselves in public. Technology can also be credited to the creation of a great number of couch potatoes. Video games, YouTube, and social media are robbing us of our exercise time. Depression, stress and poor sleep habits are increasingly becoming common medical occurrences. And of course, there is the question of privacy and security. With our entire life being online, our lives are being constantly snooped on. Your entire life history can be accessed by any stranger with a few entries on a website. Phishing, viruses, and hacking are the new forms of robbery which not only result in huge losses but also keep the perpetrator anonymous. Addiction, lack of empathy, more violence, development issues in children, lack of attention and many more issues have been associated with technology. But can we ignore the advantages that technology has offered and go back to the basics. Can we once again live like people did in the stone ages? That thought seems more far-fetched than anything else. The bottom line is—you cannot escape technology. So how you use it and how much you allow it to pervade your life is entirely in your hands. Whether you love it or hate it, technology is here to stay!
Rated 4.0/5 based on 2 customer reviews
1173
Evolution Of Technology, It’s Important To Life

Our conflicting views on whether technology is a b... Read More

DevOps In 5 letters: Should We Say CALMS or CALMR?

When someone asks me to explain what DevOps is about, I usually do this using the different letters of the acronym CALMS.CultureCulture is the foundation of DevOps. If you omit culture, you're only doing some symptoms of DevOps (like using a whiteboard, working in timeboxes and doing daily standup meetings won't make you an Agile team).Culture is about the people, about self-organized teams, about T-shaped profiles, about tearing down the wall between Development and Operations. A DevOps team takes end-to-end responsibility of an application or system: "you build it, you run it".If your organization has always been working in a command-and-control style, then the first thing to do is to instill a culture of team empowerment. And don’t underestimate this: this will probably take years to change.AutomationThis is where a lot of focus goes into and can be considered as the easiest to obtain. The heart of DevOps is the CI/CD pipeline: the continuous flow process that is triggered upon check-in of new versions of code. Continuous integration was already known in eXtreme Programming. In a DevOps context, the continuous delivery/deployment makes the story complete. To make your CI/CD pipeline work at its full capacity, you have to consider everything as code:Your source code of courseYour automated tests - unit tests, integration tests and so onYour configurationIncluding your infrastructure configurationYour database changesYour documentationBut automation is also about closing the feedback loop: getting observations, metrics from running system fed back into your team’s product backlog.Lean principlesDevOps is not about moving big chunks of changes to production, but instead, moving to a constant flow of small and easier to control changes. Flow, as in Kanban: limited work in progress, small batches. And moving to the production does not automatically mean: "going live". If there is a dependency with other code that is not yet ready, you can still disable your code via feature toggling until everything is ready to be activated.MeasuringThis is crucial to improving: define metrics on your process. How good are the things going in your organisation? Where is room for improvement? And the apply the typical Plan-Do-Check-Act/Adjust approach to gradually improve your way of working.SharingDevOps teams take full responsibility over their system. But this does not mean that they have to reinvent the wheel over and over again. They learn from their peers.Common senseThere are plenty of resources on the internet - blogs, pictures, slide decks and videos - that explain DevOps using this CALMS acronym. So by now, this acronym has become common sense for anyone who searched for some kind of definition of DevOps. Or hasn't it…?DevOps according to SAFe®, in 5 slightly different lettersRecently I had a discussion with a colleague who is a certified SAFe® Program Consultant and trainer. According to this colleague, SAFe® doesn’t talk about CALMS but about CALMR instead. She wanted to be sure we tell the same story and don’t confuse the people we train and coach. I am not going to give a full explanation of SAFe's definition of Devops, you can read it yourself on the SAFe® site (more specifically on this page www.scaledagileframework.com/devops).But I will briefly explain what the acronym CALMR stands for according to SAFe®:Culture of sharing responsibilityAutomation of continuous delivery pipelineLean flow accelerates deliveryMeasurement of everythingRecovery enables low-risk releasesThis discussion made me wonder: if a large part of the world talks about CALMS to define the principles of DevOps, then why does SAFe® talk about CALMR and what is the difference? And why do they call it "SAFe® DevOps"? So I did some investigation and this is what I found.What's the difference?In all honesty, whether you speak about CALMS or CALMR, in the end, both are equal, or better, equivalent. Let me explain why.In the CALMS acronym, the S stand for sharing. Sharing of knowledge, of experiences. Call it communities, or chapters and guilds if you are more into the way Spotify works. I deliberately don't call it "the Spotify model" because there is no Spotify Model (says Marcin Floryan, a Spotify chapter lead in this presentation: https://www.infoq.com/presentations/spotify-culture-stc).But that’s entirely different story.Sharing in CALMRIn "SAFe® DevOps", sharing is a part of the Culture. People work in teams. But teams together form a release train. So, these teams will not only need to align planning-wise, they also inspect and adapt during the IP sprint. And they learn continuously. OK, fair point. But sharing clearly is there in both definitions.Recovery in CALMSSo, what about the recovery aspect of SAFe® DevOps? Is it a part of the CALMS acronym too? In my opinion, yes, of course, divided over other aspects. The first thing that the SAFe® site tells about Recovery is "Stop the line mentality".Now, that is a Lean principle. Mary Poppendieck (Lean Software Development) mentions this in her presentations: "The greatest productivity comes from not tolerating defects. Create ways to detect defects the moment they occur” (see slide deck https://accu.org/content/conf2007/Poppendieck-Stop_the_Line_Quality.pdf ).The other parts, Plan for and rehearse failure and Build the environment and capability to fix forward and roll back, these are typically automation aspects. Plan for and rehearse failure talks about the chaos monkey.The Simian Army is a bunch of tools and concepts that will create chaos in your ecosystem: kill processes, slow down processing and so on. Chaos engineering is really great, but most likely not the first thing you will implement (even though it is a very good enabler for resilience). More information on the Simian Army can be found on the Blog of Netflix. (https://medium.com/netflix-techblog/the-netflix-simian-army-16e57fbab116).Fix forward or roll back: these are the capabilities of your CI/CD pipeline, the heart of your automation efforts in DevOps. Your Continuous deployment should allow to roll back changes. Or do canary releases: for certain changes you don't go full park all the way, but deploy on a very limited set of servers/containers as a try-out and roll back if "the canary dies".ConclusionI could not find any explanation on the internet why SAFe® talks about SAFe® DevOps. The only thing I can think of is that they want to stress how DevOps culture, principles and practices seamlessly integrate with SAFe®. Similarly, SAFe® talks about SAFe® ScrumXP, where the good practices of Scrum and eXtreme Programming help to deliver good quality software every iteration and every program increment, not only on team level, but integrated with the other teams of the Agile Release Train.As far as the difference between CALMS and CALMR is concerned: they both cover the same ideas. In my humble opinion, the difference between CALMS and CALMR could be a matter of focus: maybe the initial focus of CALMS was to stress the importance of sharing knowledge, whereas the CALMR stresses more the need to be able to roll back a failing change.Bottomline, CALMS and CALMR may not be entirely equal, but they are definitely equivalent.Anyway:
Rated 4.0/5 based on 0 customer reviews
DevOps In 5 letters: Should We Say CALMS or CALMR?

When someone asks me to explain what DevOps is abo... Read More

other Blogs